Second Half_2, New York City FC, Martinez, 15 (Rodriguez), 65th; 3, Cincinnati, Acosta, 13 (penalty kick), 69th; 4, New York City FC, Rodriguez, 10 (penalty kick), 75th; 5, Cincinnati, Baird, 3, ...
Teenager Mitja Ilenic scored his first career goal and Santiago Rodríguez scored on a penalty kick and added an assist, leading New York City to a 3-2 victory over FC Cincinnati.